News > Press Releases

Justice Minister McLellan Votes Against Bill to Fight Domestic Violence

Wednesday, May 3, 2000

OTTAWA-Today Jay Hill, MP is questioning why Ann McLellan, the Justice Minister, voted against Bill C-223 (The Witness and Spousal Protection Act) even though it passed second reading by a slim margin of 115 in favour, to 109 opposed. 17 backbench Liberal MPs supported the bill.

In speeches prepared by the Justice Minister’s department, it was stated that Bill C-223 is a good effort on the part of Mr. Hill, but it is not the right answer to solve the problem. Yet no suggestions were brought forward on the part of the government.

"I don’t claim to hold all the answers, in fact I wrote to the Minister last week and urged her to support my bill as a means of addressing the issues of domestic violence, violence against women and spousal abuse. I stated clearly that I was open to co-operation, that I would adopt the recommendations of the Committee if they found a better way to address these travesties. I don’t understand why she voted against it," stated Hill.

The bill now goes to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights for further study and possible amendment. Witnesses will appear and give testimony before the committee on a wide array of related issues to help the Committee comprehend the full extent of the proposed legislation.

"Ann McLellan has not delivered on any of the Justice issues that are important to Canadians. Instead she has become a rubber stamp for implementing the will of the courts. Two women die every week in Canada at the hands of their present or former spouse. That is a statistic that I can’t live with, and that is why I brought forward my bill. If she won’t take action on issues that kill hundreds of Canadians, she should not stand in the way of the Members of Parliament who do," Hill added.

"I hope the testimony that will be brought forward by the victims, experts and frontline workers will help convince Minister McLellan to work with the Committee to find the solutions to these travesties," concluded Hill